Compare two sentences: "Don't you like it?" and "Isn't it great?" Both begin with a negative word and look like questions. Yet the first usually rises and the second usually falls. The melody tells the listener whether you really want information or just want agreement.
If you use the wrong melody, "Aren't you coming?" can sound like you are scolding instead of showing surprise.
The Rule
A negative yes/no question has two main jobs, and each has its own melody:
- A real question, with surprise or doubt: rising intonation. "Aren't you coming?" means "I thought you were; is that wrong?" The pitch peaks on the negative auxiliary (AREN'T) and stays high or rises at the end. "Haven't you finished yet?" and "Don't you like pizza?" work the same way.
- An exclamation seeking agreement: falling intonation. "Isn't it beautiful?" means "It is beautiful, right?" The peak lands on the key word (BEAU-tiful) and then the pitch falls. It sounds like a tag question: "It's beautiful, isn't it?"
- A polite offer or invitation: gentle rise. "Wouldn't you like some tea?" is warmer than "Would you like some tea?" because it assumes you might say yes.
The pronunciation detail: the negative auxiliary carries the stress and uses its full vowel, but the /t/ is soft or silent before another consonant. "Don't you" often becomes "doan-chu" (the /t/ and /j/ blend to /tʃ/), and "wouldn't" is /ˈwʊdnt/ with a glottal stop or no /t/ at all.
Practice Words
Exceptions to Watch For
Be careful with these cases:
- Answering. English answers match the facts, not the question's negative form. "Don't you like it?" "Yes, I do" means you like it; "No, I don't" means you do not. Speakers of languages with a special word for this (French si, German doch) must use yes, I do in English.
- Formal, uncontracted questions. "Do you not like it?" and "Is it not beautiful?" sound formal or old-fashioned and are usually spoken with a rise. Native speakers prefer the contracted form in speech.
- Why-questions. "Why don't you try it?" is a suggestion and falls, not rises: it is not really asking why.
- Rhetorical use. A falling "Aren't you ashamed?" is an accusation, not a question. Check the context before you copy the tone.
Quick Tip
Take the sentence "Isn't it a nice day?" and say it twice. First with a fall, as if you are sharing a pleasure: "Isn't it a NICE day." Then with a rise on isn't, as if you are surprised: "ISN'T it a nice day?" Record both. The fall should feel complete and warm, the rise curious and slightly puzzled.