Someone says, "I bought a boat." You can respond with a normal question, "What kind of boat?" or with an echo question: "You bought a BOAT?" The echo repeats what you heard, and it does one of two jobs: it checks that you heard correctly, or it shows surprise.
The words are almost the same as a statement. The difference is carried almost entirely by pitch.
The Rule
An echo question has three features:
- Statement word order. You do not flip the subject and verb. "He quit his job" becomes "He quit his JOB?" not "Did he quit his job?"
- The repeated or questioned word is stressed, and the pitch rises on it. The rise starts low on that stressed syllable and climbs. Surprise needs a wider, higher rise; a simple check needs a smaller one.
- A wh-word replaces the missing information, and it gets the strongest stress. "You bought WHAT?" "She married WHO?" The wh-word sits at the end, not at the start.
Compare the two intonations: the normal question "What did you buy?" falls on the final word (buy), while the echo "You bought WHAT?" rises on what. This is the whole rule: real wh-questions fall; echo wh-questions rise.
Practice Words
Exceptions to Watch For
If an echo question is spoken with a falling tone, it does not sound like a question. "You bought WHAT." sounds flat, cold, or angry, which can be useful but is a different message. Also, a polite request for repetition is usually a plain wh-question with a fall: "What did you say?" and "Sorry, what was that?" End with a mild rise only if you want to sound softer: "Sorry?" Finally, in very fast speech, the word before the stressed one stays low, so do not raise the whole sentence, only the target word.
Quick Tip
Record yourself saying: "She moved to Alaska." Then answer as an echo: "She moved to ALASKA?" The pitch of the second recording should jump up on Alaska and stay high until the end. If it dips, you are making a statement.